Suggestions by @castlogic

Max Thieriot

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Miles Teller

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Andy Mientus

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Jeremy Jordan

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Jack Quaid

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Austin Abrams

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Augustus Prew

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Garrett Clayton

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Ray Nicholson

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Zac Efron

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Landon Taverniér

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Jonah Hauer-King

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Kyle Gallner

as Richie McGinniss in Kyle

Score: +1

Alex Wolff

as Anmol Khindri in Kyle

Score: +1

Shazad Latif

as Sahil Khindri in Kyle

Score: +1

Amir El-Masry

as Sahil Khindri in Kyle

Score: +1

Tony Revolori

as Sahil Khindri in Kyle

Score: +1

Ronny Mathew

as Sahil Khindri in Kyle

Score: +1

Anand Bhatt

as Sahil Khindri in Kyle

Score: +1