Suggestions by @casting666
510 suggestions
Camila Mendes
as Cordelia Charisma Chase in Sunnydale Season 2
Hunter Schafer
as Oz in Sunnydale Season 2
Nicholas Galitzine
as Angel in Sunnydale Season 2
James Marsters
as Rupert Giles in Sunnydale Season 2
Booboo Stewart
as Xander Harris in Sunnydale Season 2
Amandla Stenberg
as Willow Rosenberg in Sunnydale Season 2
Sydney Sweeney
as Buffy Anne Summers in Sunnydale Season 2
Kodi Smit-McPhee
as Ford in Sunnydale Season 2
Rob Mac
as Willy 'Emerald' the Snitch in Sunnydale Season 1
Rob McElhenney
as Willy 'Emerald' the Snitch in Sunnydale Season 1
Will Poulter
as Kyle Hauer in Sunnydale Season 1
Bella Thorne
as Heidi Kelley in Sunnydale Season 1
Mila Kunis
as Ms French in Sunnydale Season 1
Skyler Gisondo
as Jesse McNally in Sunnydale Season 1
Gus Kenworthy
as Larry Blaisdell in Sunnydale Season 1
Kathy Najimy
as Principal Flutie in Sunnydale Season 1
Jaylen Barron
as Amy Madison in Sunnydale Season 1
Rico Rodriguez
as Jonathan Levinson in Sunnydale Season 1
Mark Indelicato
as Harmony Kendall-Andrews in Sunnydale Season 1
Juno Temple
as Darla in Sunnydale Season 1