Suggestions by @castawhey

Don Johnson

as Officer Hummell in Jingle All the Way

Score: 0

Ed Sheeran

as Cohan in The Sims: Bustin Out

Score: +1

Christina Ricci

as Charlotte Powers in This is Me

Score: +1

Samara Weaving

as Iona McDougall in Gloryhammer

Score: +1

Jess Gabor

as Mattie in Sadie

Score: +1

Anderson Cooper

as Mortimer Goth in The Sims 2 Pleasantview

Score: -3

Lev Gorn

as Nikolai Kotova in Amour Amour

Score: +1

Alicia Witt

as Valerian in Valérian and Laureline

Score: +3

Mike Vogel

as President in Jingle All the Way

Score: +1

Poppy Montgomery

as Liz Langston in Jingle All the Way

Score: +3

Kevin Spacey

as Mall Santa in Jingle All the Way

Score: -2

Sebastian Stan

as Howard Langston in Jingle All the Way

Score: -3

Max Vento

as Jamie Langston in Jingle All the Way

Score: +2