Suggestions by @calebbanez

Danny Elfman

as Composer in Cats

Score: +1

T.S. Elliot

as Writer in Cats

Score: +1

Andrew Lloyd Webber

as Producer in Cats

Score: +1

Steven Spielberg

as Director in Cats

Score: +1

Diana Rice

as Gracelora in Cats

Score: +1

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

as Bumblepots in Cats

Score: +1

Elaine Paige

as Grizabella in Cats

Score: +2

Jeremy Irons

as Macavity in Cats

Score: +1

Michael Keaton

as Growltiger in Cats

Score: +1

Dick Van Dyke

as Gus in Cats

Score: +1

Gregory Peck

as Gus in Cats

Score: +1

Robin Williams

as Bustopher Jones in Cats

Score: +1

Micheal Jackson

as Rum tum tugger in Cats

Score: +1

James Earl Jones

as Old Deuteronomy in Cats

Score: +1

Martin Short

as Mr. Mistoffelees in Cats

Score: +1

Elisabeth Shue

as Demeter in Cats

Score: +1

Micheal Jackson

as Rum tum tugger in Cats (Amblimation)

Score: +3