Suggestions by @c3rtii456

Hayden Summerall

as Elliot Vance in It Lives Beneath

Score: +1

Booboo Stewart

as Tomoichi Sato in It Lives Beneath

Score: +1

Martin Cummins

as Abraham Kelley in It Lives Beneath

Score: +1

Matthew Broderick

as Richard Sutcliffe in It Lives Beneath

Score: +1

Karl Markovics

as Arthur Vance in It Lives Beneath

Score: +2

Karan Brar

as Nishan Khandaar in High School Story 3: Spring Quarter

Score: +1

Anne Winters

as Kara Sinclair in High School Story 2: Winter Quarter

Score: 0

Luke Benward

as Max Warren in High School Story 2: Winter Quarter

Score: +1

Jacob Latimore

as Caleb Mitchell in High School Story 2: Winter Quarter

Score: +1

Rob Letterman

as Producer in High School Story

Score: +1

Scott Alexander

as Writer in High School Story

Score: +1

Anne Winters

as Kara Sinclair in High School Story

Score: +1

Luke Benward

as Max Warren in High School Story

Score: +1

Justin Prentice

as Ben in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +2

Selena Gomez

as Jocelyn Wu in It Lives in the Woods

Score: 0

Bradley Cooper

as Cid in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Redfield 2.0 in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +2

Booboo Stewart

as Tom in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +1

Austin Falk

as Cody in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +1

Danielle Campbell

as Britney in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +1