Suggestions by @c3rtii456

David Oyelowo

as Charles Cooper in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +1

Zendaya

as Imogen Wescott in It Lives Beneath

Score: +1

Tyrel Jackson Williams

as Jayden Vance in It Lives Beneath

Score: +1

Sierra Aylina McClain

as Erin Ward in High School Story: Class Act

Score: +1

Camila Mendes

as Maria Flores in High School Story: Class Act

Score: +1

Joseph Kyle Pack

as Billy Carter in High School Story: Class Act

Score: +1

Julia Michaels

as Morgan Jennings in High School Story 2: Winter Quarter

Score: +1

Luke Benward

as Max Warren in High School Story 3: Spring Quarter

Score: +1

Anne Winters

as Kara Sinclair in High School Story 3: Spring Quarter

Score: +1

Julia Michaels

as Morgan Jennings in High School Story 3: Spring Quarter

Score: +1

Joseph Kyle Pack

as Billy Carter in High School Story 3: Spring Quarter

Score: +1

Joseph Kyle Pack

as Billy Carter in High School Story 2: Winter Quarter

Score: +1

Julia Michaels

as Morgan Jennings in High School Story

Score: +1

Madison Pettis

as Jade Ali in High School Story: Class Act

Score: +3

Nick Robinson

as Liam Jenkins in High School Story: Class Act

Score: +1

Abigail Cowen

as Skye Crandall in High School Story: Class Act

Score: 0

Beanie Feldstein

as Lily Ortiz in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +3

Nathan Chen

as Andy Kang in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +3

Aliya Will

as Ava Dolores Cunningham in It Lives in the Woods

Score: +4

Samantha Cormier

as Skye Crandall in High School Story: Class Act

Score: 0