Suggestions by @bwaynerd

John Travolta

as Grease in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Michael Ball

as Les Miserables in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Patti LuPone

as Les Miserables in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: +1

Colm Wilkinson

as Les Miserables in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Jason Donovan

as Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Sheridan Smith

as Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Danielle Hope

as Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: +1

Eric Anderson

as Waitress in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Kimiko Glenn

as Waitress in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Keala Settle

as Waitress in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Jessie Mueller

as Waitress in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Jennifer Barnhart

as Avenue Q in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: +2

Jordan Gelber

as Avenue Q in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: +1

Ann Harada

as Avenue Q in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: +1

Natalie Venetia Belcon

as Avenue Q in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: +1

Rick Lyon

as Avenue Q in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: +1

Stephanie D'Abruzzo

as Avenue Q in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: +2

John Tartaglia

as Avenue Q in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: +2

Wesley Taylor

as Spongebob Squarepants in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0

Gavin K. Lee

as Spongebob Squarepants in Musical Theatre Face Claims

Score: 0