Suggestions by @bwaldorf

Mallory Bechtel

as Grace Hadley (ghost) in The Hotel Nantucket

Score: +10

Malia Baker

as Edie in The Hotel Nantucket

Score: +4

Megan Fox

as Alessandra in The Hotel Nantucket

Score: -5

Larisa Oleynik

as Lizbeth Keaton in The Hotel Nantucket

Score: -6

Octavia Spencer

as Magda in The Hotel Nantucket

Score: +3

Kirsten Dunst

as Lizbeth Keaton in The Hotel Nantucket

Score: -11

Carey Mulligan

as Lily in Daisy Darker

Score: -1

Carey Mulligan

as Daisy in Daisy Darker

Score: -4

Austin Butler

as Conor in Daisy Darker

Score: -4

Maude Apatow

as Trixie in Daisy Darker

Score: -3

Meg Donnelly

as Lily Wilder in Something Wilder

Score: -5

Dylan O'Brien

as Walter in Something Wilder

Score: 0

Lucas Till

as Bradley in Something Wilder

Score: +7

Jake Abel

as Bradley in Something Wilder

Score: -1

Devyn Nekoda

as Cora in Something Wilder

Score: +5

Milo Manheim

as Leo in Something Wilder

Score: -10

Sabrina Carpenter

as Nicole in Something Wilder

Score: -4

Lana Condor

as Emily Goldrich in Josh and Hazel's Guide to Not Dating

Score: +9

Eddie Liu

as Josh Im in Josh and Hazel's Guide to Not Dating

Score: -5

Justin Baldoni

as Ethan Thomas in The Unhoneymooners

Score: -11