Suggestions by @bumblebee52s

Anthony Ramos

as Inigo Montoya in The Princess Bride

Score: +1

Talia Ryder

as Nancy Thompson in A Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: -2

Maddie Ziegler

as Tina Gray in A Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: -1

Asher Angel

as Glen Lantz in A Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: +2

Finn Wolfhard

as Rod Lane in A Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: 0

Josh Brolin

as Freddy Krueger in A Nightmare on Elm Street

Score: 0

Kristen Stewart

as Iona in Pretty in Pink

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Blane in Pretty in Pink

Score: +2

Ross Lynch

as Steff in Pretty in Pink

Score: +1

Cole Sprouse

as Ducky in Pretty in Pink

Score: +1

Bella Thorne

as Andie in Pretty in Pink

Score: +1