Suggestions by @buffalofox
320 suggestions
Brock Lesnar
as Ivan Drago in Rocky
Score: +11
Lincoln Melcher
as Young Robert Balboa in Rocky
Score: +4
Paul Dano
as Mick Mulvaney in Mulvaney
Score: +2
Jon Hamm
as Mitt Romney in Mulvaney
Score: +1
Jon Bernthal
as Bruno Sammartino in American Crime Story
Score: +2
Bill Hader
as The Cat in the Hat in The SCU
Score: +4
John C. Reilly
as Thing 2 in The SCU
Score: +2
Will Ferrell
as Thing 1 in The SCU
Score: +2
Jesse L. Martin
as Marvin Gaye in Sexual Healing: The Marvin Gaye Story
Score: +8
Freddie Highmore
as Charles R. Webb in Nichols
Score: +1
Clark Duke
as Roger Ebert in Nichols
Score: +1
Dylan Minnette
as Art Garfunkel in Nichols
Score: -1
Thomas Brodie-Sangster
as Paul Simon in Nichols
Score: 0
Luke Perry
as Lawrence Turman in Nichols
Score: +1
Miles Teller
as Gene Hackman in Nichols
Score: 0
Gwilym Lee
as Richard Burton in Nichols
Score: +1
Liv Tyler
as Elizabeth Taylor in Nichols
Score: 0
Winona Ryder
as Natalie Wood in Nichols
Score: +1
Rachel Weisz
as Ava Gardner in Nichols
Score: +1
Michelle Pfeiffer
as Lauren Bacall in Nichols
Score: +1