Suggestions by @bubblegrunge

Finn Wolfhard

as Zayn Darkshadow in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Arica Himmel

as Zelda Donovan in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Siobhan Thompson

as Arianwen Abernant in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Emily Axford

as Doreen in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Chloe Coleman

as Penny Luckstone in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Porter Cliffbreaker in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Dave Bautista

as Coach Daybreak in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Ariana Greenblatt

as Penelope Everpetal in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Zac Oyama

as Gorbag in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Johnny Galecki

as Digby Thistlespring in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Deedee Magno Hall

as Wilma Thistlespring in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Constance Wu

as Wilma Thistlespring in Fantasy High

Score: -1

Bill Hader

as Digby Thistlespring in Fantasy High

Score: -1

Milly Alcock

as Aelwyn Abernant in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Kit Connor

as Ragh Barkrock in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Elva Guerra

as Tracker O'Shaughnessey in Fantasy High

Score: +1

David Castañeda

as Jawbone O'Shaughnessey in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Ashly Burch

as Sklonda Gukgak in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Lou Wilson

as Bill Seacaster in Fantasy High

Score: +1

Emily Axford

as Sandra Lynn Faeth in Fantasy High

Score: +1