Suggestions by @bsav17

Sabrina Carpenter

as Sarah Sanderson in Hocus Pocus: The Musical

Score: +1

Chappell Roan

as Winifred Sanderson in Hocus Pocus: The Musical

Score: +2

Robert De Niro

as Santa Claus in The Nightmare Before Christmas

Score: +2

Danny Elfman

as Composer in The Nightmare Before Christmas

Score: +1

Henry Selick

as Producer in The Nightmare Before Christmas

Score: +1

Tim Burton

as Writer in The Nightmare Before Christmas

Score: +1

Neil Gaiman

as Writer in Coraline

Score: +1

Henry Selick

as Producer in Coraline

Score: +1

Tim Burton

as Director in Coraline

Score: +1

Tim Burton

as Director in The Nightmare Before Christmas

Score: +1

Whoopi Goldberg

as Mrs. Lovat in Coraline

Score: +1

Chase Dillon

as Wybie Lovat in Coraline

Score: +1

Jim Carrey

as Mr. Bobinsky in Coraline

Score: +1

Bette Midler

as Mrs. Miriam Forcible in Coraline

Score: +1

Helena Bonham Carter

as Mrs. April Spink in Coraline

Score: +1

Morgan Freeman

as The Cat in Coraline

Score: +1

Ryan Gosling

as The Other Father in Coraline

Score: +1

Elizabeth Olsen

as The Other Mother in Coraline

Score: +1

Jenna Ortega

as Coraline Jones in Coraline

Score: +1

Grant Feely

as Barrel in The Nightmare Before Christmas

Score: +1