Suggestions by @brutalraynor

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Quentin Beck (Earth-199999) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Catero Colbert

as Killer Bee in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Brie Larson

as Carol Danvers (Earth-X) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Melissa Benoist

as Kara Zor-El (Earth-X) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Kal-El (Earth-X) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Ciarán Hinds

as Steppenwolf (Earth-1) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Ethan Embry

as Max Dillon (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Neil Patrick Harris

as Peter Parker (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Fred Henderson

as Howard Stark (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Catherine Lough Haggquist

as Roberta Rhodes (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Jeffrey Bowyer-Chapman

as T'Challa (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Mark Gibbon

as Bruce Banner (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Dean Redman

as Nick Fury (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Andrew Francis

as Clint Barton (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Ashleigh Ball

as Natasha Romanoff (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Anna Cummer

as Patricia Potts (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Daniel Bacon

as James Rhodes (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Adrian Petriw

as Tony Stark (Earth-904913) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Italia Ricci

as Siobhan Smythe (Earth-38) in When Legends meet

Score: +1

Brit Morgan

as Leslie Willis (Earth-38) in When Legends meet

Score: +1