Suggestions by @brinley

Sebastian Stan

as Aspen in The Selection Series

Score: -61

Georgie Henley

as May Singer in The Selection Series

Score: -42

Lily James

as Lucy in The Selection Series

Score: -25

Emma Watson

as Kriss in The Selection Series

Score: -31

Lana Parrilla

as Silvia in The Selection Series

Score: +4

Shailene Woodley

as Marlee in The Selection Series

Score: -39

Merritt Patterson

as Celeste in The Selection Series

Score: -45

William Moseley

as Maxon in The Selection Series

Score: -65

Audrey Hollister

as America in The Selection Series

Score: +142

Alan Menken

as Composer in Tangled

Score: +7

Mandy Moore

as Rapunzel in Tangled

Score: -19

Donna Murphy

as Mother Gothel in Tangled

Score: +2