Suggestions by @brendancrowley

Neil Patrick Harris

as Nygma/ Riddler in Gotham Uprising

Score: +1

Winona Ryder

as Nora Fires in Tim Burton’s Batman and Robin

Score: +3

Anthony Perkins

as Scarecrow in Batman '66 Villains

Score: +6

Pat Hingle

as Commissioner Gordon in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin

Score: +2

Jeff Goldblum

as Scarecrow in Tim Burton's Batman and Robin

Score: 0

Kelly Preston

as Nora Fries in Batman and Robin (Tim Burton Version)

Score: +1

Lisa Marie

as Poison Ivy in Batman and Robin (Tim Burton Version)

Score: -2

Mike Myers

as Mad Hatter/Jarvis Tech in Fan Casting Mad Hatter/Jarvis Tech Matt Reeves The Batman

Score: +2

Ally Sheedy

as Harleen Quinzel in Batman Continues

Score: +1

Lori Petty

as Harleen Quinzel in Batman Continues

Score: +1

Christina Ricci

as Barbara Gordon in Batman Continues

Score: +1

Jamie Foxx

as Jason Todd in Batman Continues

Score: +1

Ernie Hudson

as Lucius Fox in Batman Continues

Score: +2

Richard Roundtree

as Lucius Fox in Batman Continues

Score: +2

Alex Rocco

as Oswald Cobblepot in Batman Returns (1982)

Score: +1

Lorraine Bracco

as Selina Kyle in Batman Returns (1982)

Score: 0

Dale Midkiff

as Harvey Dent in Alternate Casting: Batman '89

Score: +2

John Michael Higgins

as The Riddler in Batman The Brave And The Bold (Live Action)

Score: +1

Salma Hayek Pinault

as Roxanne Feder in Grown Ups 3

Score: +1

Dennis Farina

as Carmine Falcone in Batman: The Long Halloween (1997)

Score: +1