Suggestions by @brayy

Barry Keoghan

as Dandy Mott in American Horror Story Recast

Score: +1

Audra McDonald

as Desiree Dupree in American Horror Story Recast

Score: 0

Hunter Schafer

as Misty Day in American Horror Story Recast

Score: +1

Diane Keaton

as Fiona Goode in American Horror Story Recast

Score: 0

Tati Gabrielle

as Hayden McClaine in American Horror Story Recast

Score: 0

Joan Cusack

as Constance Langdon in American Horror Story Recast

Score: +4

Fiona Shaw

as Madame Delphine LaLaurie in American Horror Story Recast

Score: +1

Danielle Brooks

as Queenie in American Horror Story Recast

Score: +1

Carla Gugino

as Vivien Harmon in American Horror Story Recast

Score: 0

Rachel Weisz

as Olivia in Haunting of Hill House Recast

Score: +1

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Mrs. Hagstrom in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1

Nuha Jes Izman

as Tanya Spirko in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1

Grace Van Dien

as Ashley in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1

Lulu Wilson

as Joanne Davis in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1

Chandler Kinney

as Lilly Marsen in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1

Jessica Marie Garcia

as Carrie Mae Staten in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1

Maude Apatow

as Harmony Bowels in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1

Dafne Keen

as Mona Rita in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1

Elsie Fisher

as Natalie Sandler in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1

Jack Quaid

as Oliver Hauser in The House Bunny (2024 Remake)

Score: +1