Suggestions by @brayy
771 suggestions
Russell Tovey
as Liz Taylor in American Horror Story Recast
Score: +1
Lauren Potter
as Nan in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
George Burcea
as Spalding in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Carel Struycken
as Twisty the Clown in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Kyra Sedgwick
as Sister Jude in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Anika Noni Rose
as Ramona Royale in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Cameron Monaghan
as Michael Langdon in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Brianna Hildebrand
as Grace Bertrand in American Horror Story Recast
Score: +1
Kate Mulgrew
as Agnes Mary Winstead (The Butcher) in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Ben Schwartz
as Sidney Aaron James in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Charlie Cox
as Dylan in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Woody Harrelson
as Willaim Van Henderson in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Riley Keough
as Billie Dean Howard in American Horror Story Recast
Score: +3
Rudy Pankow
as Rory Monahan in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Sterling K. Brown
as Matt Miller in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Isaiah Mustafa
as Dominic Banks in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Mia Wasikowska
as Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Cynthia Nixon
as Audrey Tindall in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Shanola Hampton
as Monet Tumsiime in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0
Aisha Tyler
as Lee Harris in American Horror Story Recast
Score: 0