Suggestions by @braytonsavage

Zoë Kravitz

as Selina Kyle in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

Lauren Cohan

as Martha Wayne in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Thomas Wayne in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

David Thewlis

as Alfred Pennyworth in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

Anthony Daniels

as Alfred Pennyworth in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

Joshua Jackson

as James Gordon in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

James Marsden

as James Gordon in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

Iain Armitage

as Young Dick Grayson in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

Archie Barnes

as Young Dick Grayson in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

Matt Bomer

as Bruce Wayne in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: -1

Jensen Ackles

as Bruce Wayne in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +1

Robert Pattinson

as Bruce Wayne in Allen Coulter's 'The Long Halloween' (story removed)

Score: +2