Suggestions by @bookworm101

Penn Badgley

as Winston Pratt in Renegades

Score: +5

Sofia Wylie

as Winter in The Lunar Chronicles

Score: -12

Gal Gadot

as Tamaya Rae in Renegades

Score: +13

Lucy Liu

as Kasumi Hasegawa in Renegades

Score: +13

Isaak Presley

as Oscar Silva in Renegades

Score: -3

Tom Hiddleston

as Alec Artino in Renegades

Score: +16

Halle Berry

as Georgia Rawles in Renegades

Score: +7

Jennifer Aniston

as Tamaya Rae in Renegades

Score: -5

Melissa McCarthy

as Fairy Mary in Pixie Hollow - Tinker Bell Fancast

Score: +3

Sterling Knight

as Terence in Pixie Hollow - Tinker Bell Fancast

Score: +2

Sofia Carson

as Slivermist in Pixie Hollow - Tinker Bell Fancast

Score: -1

Debby Ryan

as Rosetta in Pixie Hollow - Tinker Bell Fancast

Score: +1

Anthony Mackie

as Dr Facilier in The Princess And The Frog

Score: +8

Joshua Bassett

as Young Hercules in Hercules

Score: +60

Elizabeth Gillies

as Nina Zenik in (Six of Crows &) Shadow and Bone (The Grisha Trilogy) / Grishaverse

Score: -5

Ki Hong Lee

as Kuwei-Yul-Bo in (Six of Crows &) Shadow and Bone (The Grisha Trilogy) / Grishaverse

Score: -7

Cole Sprouse

as Kaz Brekker in (Six of Crows &) Shadow and Bone (The Grisha Trilogy) / Grishaverse

Score: -10

Meg Donnelly

as Ruby in Renegades

Score: +12

Olivia Holt

as Ruby in Renegades

Score: +24

Jack Black

as Leroy Flinn in Renegades

Score: +2