Suggestions by @bohdanwayne

Ana de Armas

as Lara Croft in Tomb Raider

Score: -2

Matt Damon

as James Rodriquez in Crysis 2

Score: +5

Sam Worthington

as Kyle Crane in Dying Light

Score: +5

Sam Worthington

as Logan Carter in Dead Island

Score: +4

James Franco

as Francis Pritchard in Deus Ex: Human Revolution

Score: +3

Tom Hardy

as Jaron Namir in Deus Ex: Human Revolution

Score: +1

George Clooney

as David Sarif in Deus Ex: Human Revolution

Score: +6

Jared Leto

as Jason Michaels in Grand Theft Auto IV

Score: +1