Suggestions by @bobcannon

Tom Selleck

as Superman in 90’s Justice League

Score: +1

Clint Eastwood

as Colonel Phillips in 90’s Captain America: The First Avenger

Score: +1

Tom Cruise

as Howard Stark in 90’s Captain America: The First Avenger

Score: +2

Sigourney Weaver

as Peggy Carter in 90’s Captain America: The First Avenger

Score: +1

Bruce Willis

as Bucky Barnes in 90’s Captain America: The First Avenger

Score: +1

Ralph Fiennes

as Red Skull in 90’s Captain America: The First Avenger

Score: +2

Sylvester Stallone

as Captain America in 90’s Captain America: The First Avenger

Score: +2