Suggestions by @blueberrywine

Emilia Clarke

as Madeleine 'Max' Maxwell in Just One Damned Thing After Another

Score: +2

Daisy Head

as Isabella Barclay in Just One Damned Thing After Another

Score: -1

Colin O'Donoghue

as Leon Farrell in Just One Damned Thing After Another

Score: +2

Ruth Wilson

as Isabella Barclay in Just One Damned Thing After Another

Score: +3

Aimee Lou Wood

as Caroline in The Downstairs Girl

Score: +3

Edgar Ramírez

as Shrek in Shrek (Live Action)

Score: +1

Tyler Posey

as North in The Last Magician

Score: 0

Ludi Lin

as Jianyu in The Last Magician

Score: 0

Yoson An

as Jianyu in The Last Magician

Score: +3

C.J. LeBlanc

as Abel Johnson in The Last Magician

Score: -1

Tom Glynn-Carney

as Logan in The Last Magician

Score: 0

Nicholas Galitzine

as Harte in The Last Magician

Score: -2

Naomi Scott

as Esta in The Last Magician

Score: -4

Kristine Froseth

as Ruby in The Last Magician

Score: 0

Halle Bailey

as Cela Johnson in The Last Magician

Score: 0

Patrick Schwarzenegger

as Theo in The Last Magician

Score: +1

Valentina Bellè

as Viola in The Last Magician

Score: +2

Tom Riley

as Jack Grew in The Last Magician

Score: 0

Halle Bailey

as Cela in The Last Magician

Score: +1

Cole Sprouse

as Nibsy in The Last Magician

Score: +1