Suggestions by @bloochaos

Antje Traue

as Deputy Tara Graeme in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Ayelet Zurer

as Araya Calavera in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Amy Adams

as Lorraine Martin in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Alyssa Sutherland

as Ms. Fleming in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Amber Anderson

as Mrs. Finch in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Alicia Hannah-Kim

as Noshiko Yukimura in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Liu Yifei

as Noshiko Yukimura in Teen Wolf

Score: -1

Logan Browning

as Marin Morell in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Katie Cassidy

as Kate Argent in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Marcia Cross

as Natalie Martin in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Monica Bellucci

as Victoria Argent in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Taylor Cole

as Victoria Argent in Teen Wolf

Score: -1

Tinsel Korey

as Kali in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Zazie Beetz

as Braeden in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Haley Webb

as Jennifer Blake in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Kate Fleetwood

as Talia Hale in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Carey Mulligan

as Nurse Jennifer in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Melissa McCall in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Nicholas Hamilton

as Young Peter Hale in Teen Wolf

Score: +1

Ian Nelson

as Young Derek Hale in Teen Wolf

Score: +1