Suggestions by @blocachoodyssey

Jimmy Pesto

as 2011 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +2

Calvin Fischoeder

as 2011 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +1

Carl Showalter (Fargo)

as 1996 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +1

Colonel Frank Fitts (American Beauty)

as 1999 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +1

Lester Burnham

as 1999 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +1

Stewie Griffin

as 1999 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +1

Andy Bernard

as 2012 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +1

Robert California

as 2011 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +1

Ryan Howard (The Office)

as 2007 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +1

Tombstone (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

as 2026 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +4

Miranda Priestly

as 2026 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +1

Doofy Gilmore

as 2026 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +4

Art the Clown

as 2026 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +4

M. Bison

as 2026 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +3

Lilypad (Toy Story)

as 2026 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +2

Ghostface

as 2026 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: +3

Michelle Fuller

as 2025 in The Best Villains of the Years

Score: 0

Michael Strassner

as Simon Pearson in Red Dead Redemption 2: The Movie

Score: +2

Steven Ogg

as Reverend Swanson in Red Dead Redemption 2: The Movie

Score: 0

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Josiah Trelawny in Red Dead Redemption 2: The Movie

Score: +2