Suggestions by @bizibee

Kate Siegel

as Marla Williams in A Murder Carol

Score: +1

Sterling Jerins

as Tori Williams in A Murder Carol

Score: +1

Addison Holley

as Tori Williams in A Murder Carol

Score: 0

Alex Essoe

as Nancy Monroe in Door to Door

Score: +1

Jocelin Donahue

as Susan Andrews in Door to Door

Score: +1

Kristian Bruun

as Michael Andrews in Door to Door

Score: +1

Ingrid Rogers

as Carol Baker in Door to Door

Score: +1

Rylea Nevaeh Whittet

as Lindsay Andrews in Door to Door

Score: +1

Robert Nahum

as Sheriff John Bailey in Door to Door

Score: +1

Holly Taylor

as Cynthia Walsh in Door to Door

Score: +1

Palmer Newson

as Angie Dunn in Door to Door

Score: +1

Dane DeHaan

as Christopher Monroe in Door to Door

Score: +1

Cameron Fuller

as Roy Bellwood in Door to Door

Score: +1

Arabella Olivia Clark

as Lindsay Andrews in Door to Door

Score: +1

Daisy Edgar-Jones

as Sarah Andrews in Door to Door

Score: +1