Suggestions by @bizibee

Maitland McConnell

as Linda Ross in A Murder Carol

Score: +1

Dylan Taylor

as Gary Stephens in A Murder Carol

Score: +1

Alice Dwyer

as Delilah Stephens in A Murder Carol

Score: +1

Eva Brooke Baker

as Bridget Stephens in A Murder Carol

Score: +1

Josh Hartnett

as Sheriff Sam Taylor in A Murder Carol

Score: +1

Bruce Campbell

as George Sims in Roller Rink Massacre

Score: +1

Devon Sawa

as Sheriff Brady in Roller Rink Massacre

Score: +1

Tanner Buchanan

as Keith Watkins in Roller Rink Massacre

Score: +1

Violet Brinson

as Ronnie Gilbert in Roller Rink Massacre

Score: +1

Lizzy Greene

as Melissa Brady in Roller Rink Massacre

Score: +1

Gina Gershon

as Eleanor Cartwright in Roller Rink Massacre

Score: +1

Izzy King

as Joseph Taylor in A Murder Carol

Score: +1

Taylor Russell

as Peggy Weaver in Killer Frequency

Score: 0

Toby Regbo

as Teddy Gallows Jr. in Killer Frequency

Score: +1

Cara Buono

as Sandra Sharpe in Killer Frequency

Score: +1

Finn Wolfhard

as Henry Barrow in Killer Frequency

Score: 0

Jodhi May

as Marie Campbell in Killer Frequency

Score: -1

Skeet Ulrich

as Forrest Nash in Killer Frequency

Score: +1

Danielle Harris

as Beth Taylor in A Murder Carol

Score: +1

Elliott Fullam

as Alex Williams in A Murder Carol

Score: +1