Suggestions by @billymountiii

Jennifer Love Hewitt

as Julie James in I Know What You Did Last Summer (Reboot/Legacy Sequel)

Elizabeth Debicki

as Karen Keller/The Last Summer Killer (The Fisherman) in I Know What You Did Last Summer (Reboot/Legacy Sequel)

Alicia Vikander

as Rachel Mikkelsen in Steven & Stephanie

Rachel Leigh Cook

as Clarissa "Claire" Allen in Steven & Stephanie

Maya Hawke

as Jill "The Wild Child" Murphy in Steven & Stephanie

Madison Lintz

as Annie Thompson in Steven & Stephanie

Josephine Chavarria Højbjerg

as Stephanie Mikkelsen in Steven & Stephanie

Finn Wolfhard

as Steven Allen in Steven & Stephanie