Suggestions by @bevinward

Keanu Reeves

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Giancarlo Esposito

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Johnny Depp

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Mark Strong

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Gary Oldman

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Viggo Mortensen

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Ralph Fiennes

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Christoph Waltz

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Robert De Niro

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Willem Dafoe

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Alan van Sprang

as Marquest Haven in Shadowvale

Score: -1

Samantha Cormier

as Clary Fray in Shadowhunters

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Clary Fray in Shadowhunters

Score: +3

Rudy Pankow

as Jace Wayland in Shadowhunters

Score: -1

Jace Norman

as Jace Wayland in Shadowhunters

Score: -1

Thomas Brodie-Sangster

as Jace Wayland in Shadowhunters

Score: -1

Olivia Rodrigo

as Isabelle Lightwood in Shadowhunters

Score: +1

Caitlin Blackwood

as Indigo Fallon Hawke in Shadowvale

Score: +1

Samantha Cormier

as Indigo Fallon Hawke in Shadowvale

Score: +1

Annalise Basso

as Indigo Fallon Hawke in Shadowvale

Score: +1