Suggestions by @bethanyransom

Mckenna Grace

as Melissa Anne Montgomery in Lady in White

Score: 0

Daniel Craig

as King Graham in King's Quest

Score: +1

Johnny Depp

as Hector Bowen in The Night Circus

Score: +4

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Tara Burgess in The Night Circus

Score: -2

Natalie Portman

as Tara Burgess in The Night Circus

Score: +7

Keira Knightley

as Lainie Burgess in The Night Circus

Score: +5

Melissa McCarthy

as Cookie Kowalski in First Grave on the Right (Charley Davidson Series)

Score: +4

Rebel Wilson

as Cookie Kowalski in First Grave on the Right (Charley Davidson Series)

Score: -1

Meryl Streep

as Wickerbottom in Don't Starve

Score: +6

Ruta Gedmintas

as Kellyanne Conway in Trump

Score: +1

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Buffy Summers in Buffy the Vampire Slayer (Reboot/Remake)

Score: -1

Aneurin Barnard

as Marco Alisdair in The Night Circus

Score: +2

Christina Ricci

as Charlie in Don't Starve

Score: +5

Sophia Lillis

as Wigfrid in Don't Starve

Score: +4

Summer Glau

as Melaka Fray in Fray

Score: 0

Odeya Rush

as Melaka Fray in Fray

Score: +2

Annabelle Wallis

as Ivanka Trump in Trump

Score: +11

Tom Felton

as Spike in Buffy the Vampire Slayer (Reboot/Remake)

Score: -12

Torrance Coombs

as Sarkan, "The Dragon" in Uprooted

Score: -10

Odeya Rush

as Nora Dearly in Dearly Departed (Gone with the Respiration)

Score: +1