Suggestions by @bensalzar

Rose Byrne

as Lizz in Goth

Score: 0

Emma Watson

as Emma in Goth

Score: +7

Elizabeth Olsen

as Lizz in Teenagerz

Score: +1

Dave Franco

as Sam in Teenagerz

Score: +1

Dave Franco

as Lizz in Teenagerz

Score: -1

Tom Holland

as Billy in Teenagerz

Score: +2

Dwayne Johnson

as Leo in Teenagerz

Score: +1

Rose Byrne

as Hannia in Teenagerz

Score: +1

Ava Allan

as Marisa in Teenagerz

Score: +2

Bailee Madison

as Sara in Teenagerz

Score: +1

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Alice in Teenagerz

Score: +3

Elizabeth Olsen

as Maria in Ms. Office

Score: +1

Brie Larson

as Lizz in Ms. Office

Score: +3

Scarlett Johansson

as Sara in Ms. Office

Score: +1

Emma Watson

as Marry in Ms. Office

Score: +2

Marisa Tomei

as Sandra in Ms. Office

Score: +2