Suggestions by @bennystrikesback

Christopher Eccleston

as Player King in Hamlet

Score: +1

Eoin Macken

as Francisco in Hamlet

Score: +1

William Jackson Harper

as Bernardo in Hamlet

Score: +1

Temuera Morrison

as Marcellus in Hamlet

Score: +2

Dan Fogler

as Osric in Hamlet

Score: +1

Tom Blyth

as Guildenstern in Hamlet

Score: +2

Connor Swindells

as Rosencrantz in Hamlet

Score: +2

Ben Mendelsohn

as Polonius in Hamlet

Score: +3

Barry Keoghan

as Laertes in Hamlet

Score: +3

Joivan Wade

as Horatio in Hamlet

Score: +1

Florence Pugh

as Ophelia in Hamlet

Score: +3

Vera Farmiga

as Queen Gertrude in Hamlet

Score: +2

Paul Bettany

as King Claudius in Hamlet

Score: +3

Paul Mescal

as Prince Hamlet in Hamlet

Score: +2

Shannon Purser

as Squirrel Girl in The Avengers

Score: +3

Hannah Einbinder

as Jean Grey in The Avengers

Score: +1

Lars Mikkelsen

as Professor X in The Avengers

Score: +1

Charlize Theron

as Vereesa Windrunner in World of Warcraft Characters

Score: +1

Hiroyuki Sanada

as Nozdormu in World of Warcraft Characters

Score: +1

Domhnall Gleeson

as Liam Greymane in World of Warcraft Characters

Score: +1