Suggestions by @bennystrikesback

Andy Serkis

as Moloch the Mystic in Watchmen

Score: +1

Kyle MacLachlan

as Nite Owl I in Watchmen

Score: +2

Toni Collette

as Silk Spectre I in Watchmen

Score: +1

Lily James

as Silk Spectre II in Watchmen

Score: +1

Lars Eidinger

as Ozymandias in Watchmen

Score: +2

Jon Bernthal

as The Comedian in Watchmen

Score: 0

Cory Michael Smith

as Nite Owl II in Watchmen

Score: +2

Josh Stewart

as Rorschach in Watchmen

Score: +2

Rahul Kohli

as Doctor Manhattan in Watchmen

Score: +1

Alice Eve

as Donna Morgan in Weapons (2025)

Score: +1

Hamish Linklater

as Gary in Weapons (2025)

Score: +1

Brittany Snow

as Erica in Weapons (2025)

Score: +1

Song Kang-ho

as Marcus Miller in Weapons (2025)

Score: +1

Holt McCallany

as Ed Locke in Weapons (2025)

Score: +1

Frances Conroy

as Aunt Gladys in Weapons (2025)

Score: +3

Lucas Grant

as Alex Lilly in Weapons (2025)

Score: +1

Owen Teague

as James in Weapons (2025)

Score: +2

Christopher Abbott

as Paul Morgan in Weapons (2025)

Score: +2

Lucy Boynton

as Justine Gandy in Weapons (2025)

Score: +1

Ethan Hawke

as Archer Graff in Weapons (2025)

Score: +2