Suggestions by @batatablouse

Timothy Olyphant

as Mickey Altieri in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Scott Foley

as Roman Bridger in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Retta

as Dr. Clover Ferrero in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Nicholas Cirillo

as Kai Loomis in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Jarod Joseph

as Landon Reynolds in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Danny Nucci

as Officer Hunter Pierce in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Maya Hawke

as Stella Prescott Kincaid in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +2

Aubrey Plaza

as Mayor Marienne Gardner in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Niecy Nash-Betts

as Dakota Martin in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Simone Ashley

as Reporter Clarke Abrahams in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Joseph Quinn

as Rory Weary in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +2

Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett

as Director in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Norman Reedus

as Reporter Adam Griffin in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Rose McGowan

as Tatum Riley in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as Stu Macher in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +3

Drew Barrymore

as Casey Becker in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +3

Claudia Jessie

as Hope Velvet in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: 0

Jonathan Daviss

as Milo Nicholas in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Lauren Cohan

as Sheriff Doris Dean in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +1

Zendaya

as Poppy Bloom in Scream VII - Fan Casting

Score: +3