Suggestions by @banane

Olga Kurylenko

as Aubrey Brady in Icebreaker

Score: -3

Josh Hutcherson

as Robbie Hamlet in Icebreaker

Score: +8

Timothée Chalamet

as Aaron Carlisle in Icebreaker

Score: +3

Antonia Gentry

as Sabrina Allali in Icebreaker

Score: -3

Chris Evans

as Nathan Hawkins in Icebreaker

Score: -42

Robert Redford

as Coach Wolinski in Campus Drivers

Score: +2

Glen Powell

as Donovan Wolinski in Campus Drivers

Score: +2

Zach Roerig

as Donovan Wolinski in Campus Drivers

Score: -1

Alicia Vikander

as Amy Hitman in Campus Drivers

Score: 0

Scott Eastwood

as Lewis Conley in Campus Drivers

Score: +1

Elle Fanning

as Amelia Wolinski in Campus Drivers

Score: 0

Britt Robertson

as Amelia Wolinski in Campus Drivers

Score: +3

Melissa Benoist

as Rebecca in Campus Drivers

Score: +1

Alexandra Daddario

as Amy Hitman in Campus Drivers

Score: +3

Matthew Daddario

as Adam Johnson in Campus Drivers

Score: +4

Douglas Booth

as Adam Johnson in Campus Drivers

Score: 0

Zac Efron

as Lewis Conley in Campus Drivers

Score: +1

Milly Alcock

as Carrie Wolinski in Campus Drivers

Score: +1

Penelope Mitchell

as Carrie Wolinski in Campus Drivers

Score: +3

Rudy Pankow

as Donovan Wolinski in Campus Drivers

Score: +3