Suggestions by @baguette

Banks Repeta

as Will Sinclair in We Were Liars

Diesel La Torraca

as Johnny Sinclair in We Were Liars

Candice King

as Elizabeth Sinclair in We Were Liars

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Tipper Taft in We Were Liars

Bruce Greenwood

as Harris Sinclair in We Were Liars

Madelyn Cline

as Cadence Sinclair in We Were Liars

Meg Donnelly

as Mirren Sinclair in We Were Liars

Lili Reinhart

as Penelope Sinclair in We Were Liars

Ella Allan

as Liberty Sinclair in We Were Liars

Mia Allan

as Bonnie Sinclair in We Were Liars