Suggestions by @baconbaconbacon

Cristin Milioti

as Nora in The Midnight Library

Score: +5

Elizabeth Olsen

as Celia St. James in The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo

Score: -32

Ty Burrell

as Gabriel Emerson in Gabriel’s Inferno

Score: +1

Inbar Lavi

as Julia Mitchell in Gabriel’s Inferno

Score: +1

Christian Barillas

as Young Pablo in Next Year in Havana

Score: -2

Nathalie Emmanuel

as Beatrice in The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue

Score: -13

Michelle Fairley

as Penelope in Circe

Score: -1

Tom Ellis

as Telemachus in Circe

Score: -5

Gal Gadot

as Athena in Circe

Score: -1

Henry Cavill

as Odysseus in Circe

Score: +2

Keira Knightley

as Circe in Circe

Score: -11

Eva Green

as Circe in Circe

Score: -7

Bill Skarsgård

as Theo in The Silent Patient

Score: -22

Kit Harington

as Gabriel in The Silent Patient

Score: -8

Henry Cavill

as Gabriel in The Silent Patient

Score: +11

Maggie Smith

as Ruth in The Silent Patient

Score: +11

Eva Green

as Alicia in The Silent Patient

Score: -17

Paul Bettany

as Theo in The Silent Patient

Score: -19

Elizabeth Olsen

as Alicia in The Silent Patient

Score: -12

Paulina Gaitán

as Evelyn Hugo (young) in The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo

Score: -38