Suggestions by @austenjane1813

Amybeth McNulty

as Meredith Dardenne in If We Were Villains

Score: +3

Kit Connor

as James Farrow in If We Were Villains

Score: +1

Kit Connor

as Francis Abernathy in The Secret History (TV Series)

Score: 0

Kedar Williams-Stirling

as Richard Papen in The Secret History (TV Series)

Score: -2

Luke Newton

as Richard Papen in The Secret History (TV Series)

Score: -2

Jacob Elordi

as Henry Winter in The Secret History (TV Series)

Score: -2

Nicholas Galitzine

as Forest Winnow in Divine Rivals

Score: +18

Gugu Mbatha-Raw

as Captain Speer in Divine Rivals

Score: +4

Matt Berry

as M. Andre in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Lorena Andrea

as Marisol Torres in Divine Rivals

Score: +10

Tessa Thompson

as Marisol Torres in Divine Rivals

Score: +1

Kayvan Novak

as The Persian in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +2

Halle Bailey

as Eurydice in Hadestown

Score: +1

Chloe Bailey

as Eurydice in Hadestown

Score: +1

Sophie Turner

as June Hayward/Juniper Song in Yellowface

Score: -11

Hannah Waddingham

as Jesiba Roga in Crescent City

Score: -2

Trystan Gravelle

as Zeb Autry in Divine Rivals

Score: +8

Joely Richardson

as Aster Winnow in Divine Rivals

Score: 0

Alexander Siddig

as Zeb Autry in Divine Rivals

Score: +2

SpongeBob in Real Life

as Boq in Wicked

Score: +1