Suggestions by @attheendoftheearth

Katya Sitak

as Penny Perkins in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +2

London Fuller

as Cultist Daughter in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

Valeria Cotto

as Cultist Daughter in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

Mila Kunis

as Cultist Mother in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

Olivia Wilde

as Cultist Mother in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Suzie Simons in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +2

Sofia Wylie

as Suzie Simons in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +4

Daniel DiMaggio

as Caleb Cameron in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

Harry Collett

as Caleb Cameron in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +2

Aidan Fiske

as Caleb Cameron in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

Webb Hayes

as Caleb Cameron in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

David Mazouz

as Brandon Brown in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

Caleb McLaughlin

as Brandon Brown in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +3

Laya DeLeon Hayes

as Leila Lee in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +2

Carmel Laniado

as Martha May in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +2

Saara Chaudry

as Martha May in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

Lauren Lindsey Donzis

as Gretta Green in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: 0

Minon John

as Freddy Freeman in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +2

Rio Mangini

as Freddy Freeman in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: +1

Nicholas Hamilton

as Jamie Jones in Class of Cardinal Sin

Score: -2