Suggestions by @arrongroom

Gary Oldman

as James Gordon in The Batman (2005)

Score: +10

Wes Bentley

as Harvey Dent in The Batman (2005)

Score: 0

Walton Goggins

as The Riddler in The Batman (2005)

Score: +2

Anthony Stewart Head

as Alfred Pennyworth in The Batman (2005)

Score: -1

Eva Green

as Selina kyle in The Batman (2005)

Score: +21

Martin Wallström

as The Joker in The Batman (2005)

Score: -4

Karl Urban

as Batman in The Batman (2005)

Score: +2

Hans Zimmer

as Composer in The Batman (2005)

Score: 0

David S. Goyer

as Writer in The Batman (2005)

Score: +1

Christopher Nolan

as Director in The Batman (2005)

Score: 0

Sean Maher

as Zor-El in Superman(2005)

Score: -1

Ray Stevenson

as Bibbo Bibbowski in Superman(2005)

Score: +1

Isla Fisher

as Lana Lang in Superman(2005)

Score: 0

Michael Shannon

as General Zod in Superman(2005)

Score: 0

Laurence Fishburne

as Perry White in Superman(2005)

Score: 0

J.K. Simmons

as President Of The United States in Superman(2005)

Score: 0

Diane Lane

as Martha Kent in Superman(2005)

Score: -2

Kevin Costner

as Jonathan Kent in Superman(2005)

Score: -2

Russell Crowe

as Jor-El in Superman(2005)

Score: -1

Jamie Bell

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman(2005)

Score: 0