Suggestions by @arloherrod

Peter Grosz

as Joseph Borelli in Monster

Score: +1

Tony Hale

as Joseph Borelli in Monster

Score: -1

Jeremy Allen White

as David Berkowitz in Monster

Score: +2

Oliver Cooper

as David Berkowitz in Monster

Score: +1

Hunter Schafer

as Aldrif Odinsdottir in The Legendary Starlord

Score: +1

Shane Gillis

as Leroy Quill in The Legendary Starlord

Score: +1

Shooter Jennings

as Waylon Jennings in We Are The World

Score: +1

Saoirse Ronan

as Meredith in The Dunder Mifflin Days (2025)

Score: +1

Pilou Asbæk

as Kgbeast in Suicide Squad: 1990

Score: +1

Josh Lucas

as White Dragon in Suicide Squad: 1990

Score: +1

Maddison Jaizani

as Nightshade in Suicide Squad: 1990

Score: +1

Jamie Campbell Bower

as Icicle in Suicide Squad: 1990

Score: +1

Griffin Gluck

as Rick Flag Sr. in Suicide Squad: 1990

Score: +1

John C. McGinley

as General Wade Ailing in Suicide Squad: 1990

Score: +1

Michael Longfellow

as Adam Cray in Suicide Squad: 1990

Score: +1

Omari Hardwick

as Bronze Tiger in Suicide Squad: 1990

Score: +1

Yara Shahidi

as Amanda Waller in Suicide Squad: 1990

Score: +1

Sebastian Stan

as Ronnie Van Zant in Rockstars Biopics

Score: +1

Ama Qamata

as Tilly Carpenter in White Lotus: Africa

Score: +1

Gene Wilder

as The Wizard in The Wizard of Oz (1989)

Score: +5