Suggestions by @archieluvr

Odessa Rae

as Bella Swan in Twilight

Score: -1

Maude Apatow

as Bella Swan in Twilight

Score: +1

Mackenzie Foy

as Bella Swan in Twilight

Score: +1

Katherine Langford

as Bella Swan in Twilight

Score: +1

Margaret Qualley

as Bella Swan in Twilight

Score: +1

Margaret Qualley

as Bella Swan in Twilight

Score: -2

Sophia Lillis

as Alice Mary Brandon Cullen (Vampire) in Twilight

Score: +1

Odessa A'zion

as Alice Mary Brandon Cullen (Vampire) in Twilight

Score: +1

Lily-Rose Depp

as Rosalie Lillian Hale Cullen (Vampire) in Twilight

Score: 0

Sydney Sweeney

as Rosalie Lillian Hale Cullen (Vampire) in Twilight

Score: 0

Emily Alyn Lind

as Heather McNamara in Heathers (2018)

Score: 0

Madelyn Cline

as Heather Chandler in Heathers (2018)

Score: -1

Sydney Sweeney

as Heather Chandler in Heathers (2018)

Score: 0

Sydney Sweeney

as Catwoman in Fancast DC

Score: -2

Sofia Wylie

as Vanessa Abrams in Gossip Girl Remake

Score: +2

Sofia Bryant

as Vanessa Abrams in Gossip Girl Remake

Score: +1

Zendaya

as Vanessa Abrams in Gossip Girl Remake

Score: +1

Alisha Boe

as Vanessa Abrams in Gossip Girl Remake

Score: +1

Madison Bailey

as Vanessa Abrams in Gossip Girl Remake

Score: +2

Taissa Farmiga

as Jenny Humphrey in Gossip Girl Remake

Score: 0