Suggestions by @arandonnelly02

Kyle MacLachlan

as James Orin Incandenza in Infinite Jest

Score: +1

Sheryl Lee

as Avril Incandenza in Infinite Jest

Score: +1

Rachel McAdams

as Evelyn Cross Mulwray in Chinatown (2014)

Score: +2

Donald Sutherland

as Noah Cross in Chinatown (2014)

Score: +1

Rachel McAdams

as Evelyn Cross Mulwray in Chinatown (2014)

Score: +1

Kiefer Sutherland

as Bullseye in Daredevil ('90s)

Score: +1

Brian Dennehy

as Kingpin in Daredevil ('90s)

Score: +2

Sheryl Lee

as Karen Page in Daredevil ('90s)

Score: +1

Tim Roth

as William Wharton in The Green Mile (1999 Alternate Casting)

Score: +3

Joaquin Phoenix

as James Averill in Heaven's Gate (2020)

Score: +1

Florence Pugh

as Linda in The Deer Hunter (2025)

Score: +1

Andrew Garfield

as Nikanor Chevotarevich in The Deer Hunter (2025)

Score: +1

Nick Nolte

as Nick Chevotarevich in The Deer Hunter

Score: +2

Léa Seydoux

as Mrs. O'Brien in The Tree of Life

Score: +1

Sheryl Lee

as Mrs. O'Brien in The Tree of Life (2001)

Score: +2

Willem Dafoe

as Jack O'Brien in The Tree of Life (2001)

Score: +1

Viggo Mortensen

as Mr. O'Brien in The Tree of Life (2001)

Score: +2

Dean Stockwell

as Stanley "Stosh" in The Deer Hunter

Score: +1

Guy Pearce

as Matt Murdoch in Marvel's Daredevil (1995-1998)

Score: +1

David Thewlis

as Albert Spica in The Cook, The Thief, His Wife, and Her Lover (2023)

Score: +1