Suggestions by @arachnick28

Crispin Glover

as Phineas T. Ratchet in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +3

Willem Dafoe

as Madame Gasket in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +6

Demi Moore

as Cappy in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +8

Ashley French

as Piper Pinwheeler in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +8

James Woods

as Phineas T. Ratchet in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +3

Jeffrey Tambor

as Madame Gasket in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: -1

Ming-Na Wen

as Cappy in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +7

Catherine O'Hara

as Aunt Fanny in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +9

Wayne Knight

as Bigweld in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +11

Rupert Everett

as Phineas T. Ratchet in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +12

Eva Longoria

as Cappy in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +4

Morena Baccarin

as Cappy in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +5

Miranda Cosgrove

as Piper Pinwheeler in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: -4

Martin Short

as Fender Pinwheeler in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +9

Steve Martin

as Fender Pinwheeler in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +12

Patton Oswalt

as Fender Pinwheeler in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +6

Eddie Murphy

as Fender Pinwheeler in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +8

Michael J. Fox

as Rodney Copperbottom in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +12

Elijah Wood

as Rodney Copperbottom in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +13

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Rodney Copperbottom in Robots 2005 (Alternate Cast)

Score: +4