Suggestions by @arachnick28

Vanessa Kirby

as Supergirl in Superman

Score: +2

Amanda Seyfried

as Supergirl in Superman

Score: -2

Tim Daly

as Jonathan Kent in Superman

Score: +2

Walton Goggins

as Perry White in Superman

Score: -2

Denzel Washington

as Perry White in Superman

Score: 0

Mel Gibson

as Perry White in Superman

Score: 0

Joe Keery

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman

Score: 0

Charlie Rowe

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman

Score: +2

Tye Sheridan

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman

Score: 0

Zooey Deschanel

as Lois Lane in Superman

Score: +2

Henry Cavill

as Superman in Superman

Score: +3

Joss Ackland

as Kingpin in Spider-Man Movie Series (1990's)

Score: +2

David Kaye

as Apocalypse in Marvel Animated Universe

Score: +1

Fred Tatasciore

as Beast in Marvel Animated Universe

Score: +1

Mary Elizabeth McGlynn

as Clea in Marvel Animated Universe

Score: +1

Joss Ackland

as Kingpin in Spider-Man (1990s)

Score: +3

Martha Marion

as White Queen in Marvel Animated Universe

Score: +1

Todd Haberkorn

as Henry Peter Gyrich in Marvel Animated Universe

Score: +1

Gavin Hammon

as Bolivar Trask in Marvel Animated Universe

Score: +1

Ron Rubin

as Senator Robert Kelly in Marvel Animated Universe

Score: +1