Suggestions by @annemie12

Ben Barnes

as Legend in Caraval

Score: +3

Kaya Scodelario

as Scarlett in Caraval

Score: +1

Timothée Chalamet

as Victor Woodson in Evernight

Score: +2

Eva Green

as Charlotte Bethany in Evernight

Score: +1

Liana Liberato

as Raquel Vargas in Evernight

Score: +1

Froy Gutierrez

as Erich in Evernight

Score: +1

Katie McGrath

as Courtney Briganti in Evernight

Score: +2

Lily Collins

as Patrice Devereaux in Evernight

Score: +2

Michele Morrone

as Adrian Oliver in Evernight

Score: +1

Katie Holmes

as Celia Oliver in Evernight

Score: +1

Alex Pettyfer

as Balthazar Moore in Evernight

Score: +2

Maxence Danet-Fauvel

as Lucas Ross in Evernight

Score: +2

Emma Roberts

as Bianca Oliver in Evernight

Score: +2

Julia Adamenko

as Jenna in My Lovely Wife.

Score: +2

George Clooney

as Callahan Gentry in Confess

Score: +1

Shay Mitchell

as Emory Lee in Confess

Score: +1

George Clooney

as A.J. in Confess

Score: +1

Isabelle Huppert

as Lydia in Confess

Score: +1

Milo Ventimiglia

as Trey Taylor in Confess

Score: +1

Neels Visser

as Owen Gentry in Confess

Score: +2