Suggestions by @aniabbina

Joel Grey

as The Wizard of Oz in Wicked

Score: +4

Hugh Jackman

as The Wizard of Oz in Wicked

Score: +4

Auliʻi Cravalho

as Nessarose in Wicked

Score: -3

Zendaya

as Elphaba in Wicked

Score: -1

Michelle Williams

as Madame Morrible in Wicked

Score: -4

Angelina Jolie

as Madame Morrible in Wicked

Score: -5

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Madame Morrible in Wicked

Score: +6

Anna Kendrick

as Nessarose in Wicked

Score: +2

Lea Michele

as Nessarose in Wicked

Score: -3

Aaron Tveit

as Fiyero in Wicked

Score: +11

Zac Efron

as Fiyero in Wicked

Score: -4

Samantha Barks

as Elphaba in Wicked

Score: +23

Neil Patrick Harris

as Boq in Wicked

Score: +1

Ian McKellen

as Boq in Wicked

Score: +1

Patrick Stewart

as Boq in Wicked

Score: +1

James Corden

as Boq in Wicked

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Boq in Wicked

Score: +1

Christine Baranski

as Madame Morrible in Wicked

Score: +10

Viola Davis

as Madame Morrible in Wicked

Score: -2

Jordan Fisher

as Fiyero in Wicked

Score: +11