Suggestions by @anhay

Fortune Feimster

as Big Thelma in The Baking Games

DeVore Ledridge

as Sadie in The Baking Games

Danielle Macdonald

as Savannah in The Baking Games

Josh Stewart

as CJ Davenport (2) in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Shannon Dee

as Candace/Candy in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Rudy Pankow

as Bradley Ellison in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Tress MacNeille

as Alma Hurston in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Adelaide Kane

as April Johnson in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Tru Valentino

as Michael Portman in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Joe Keery

as Tyler Lawrence in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Johan Glans

as Paul Rivers in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Kristofer Hivju

as Jackson Abernathy in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Scott Pocha

as Chris Russell in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Patricia Belcher

as Hannah Portman in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Nick Robinson

as Leroy Danielson in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Delroy Lindo

as Garrett Kelly in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Blair Underwood

as “The Admiral” in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Carol Woods

as Octavia Montgomery in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Johan Glans

as Father Calloway in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)

Kylee Russell

as Madison Montgomery in Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder (etc.)