Suggestions by @angelacalvello

Alexander Skarsgård

as Dean in One of Us is Dead

Bridget Regan

as Karen in One of Us is Dead

Austin Butler

as Aaron Gregory in In Five Years

Emma Mackey

as April Sawicki in The People We Keep

Gemma Arterton

as April Sawicki in The People We Keep

Samara Weaving

as Sarah in Maybe in Another Life

Rafael de la Fuente

as Diego in The Unhoneymooners

Krysten Ritter

as Sherry in Things We Never Got Over

Ruby Rose

as Silver in Things We Never Got Over

Brianne Howey

as Sloane in Things We Never Got Over

Andrew Garfield

as Corey in Verity

Diana Guerrero

as Olive Torres in The Unhoneymooners

Tom Hardy

as Lucian in Things We Never Got Over

Mimi Kennedy

as Liza J in Things We Never Got Over

Chris Hemsworth

as Nash in Things We Never Got Over

Maya Hawke

as Beatrice in That Summer by Jennifer Weiner

Ginnifer Goodwin

as Adult Daisy in That Summer by Jennifer Weiner

Rachel Weisz

as Adult Diana in That Summer by Jennifer Weiner

Jamie Dornan

as Harry Cameron in The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo