Suggestions by @andreassb

Dove Cameron

as Piper in Hook line and sinker

Score: +3

Kathryn Newton

as Feyre in A Court of Thorns and Roses

Score: -54

Valentina Ferragni

as Hannah in Hook line and sinker

Score: -3

Valentina Ferragni

as Piper in Hook line and sinker

Score: -1

Florence Pugh

as Hannah in Hook line and sinker

Score: +2

Sam Claflin

as Fox Thornton in Hook line and sinker

Score: -1

Valentina Ferragni

as Piper Bellinger in It Happened One Summer

Score: -4

Lily James

as Sarah in One Day in December

Score: 0