Suggestions by @andmeggyhash

Dove Cameron

as Charlie in Hazbin Hotel Faceclaims + OC Faceclaims

Score: 0

Patrick Page

as SCP-049 in SCP Area 96 Movie (2030)

Score: -1

Patrick Page

as SCP-049 in SCP

Score: +2

Krysten Ritter

as Jerri Bartman in Count Crowley: Reluctant Midnight Monster Hunter

Score: +1

Jordan Fisher

as Anthony Hope in Sweeney Todd

Score: +1

Eva Noblezada

as Johanna Barker in Sweeney Todd

Score: +1

Audra McDonald

as Mrs Lovett in Sweeney Todd

Score: +1

Stephanie J. Block

as Mrs Lovett in Sweeney Todd

Score: +2

Hugh Dancy

as Bruce Banner in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +1

Corey Hawkins

as Sam Wilson in Rogers: the Musical

Score: 0

Sutton Foster

as Natasha Romanoff in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +1

Eden Espinosa

as Natasha Romanoff in Rogers: the Musical

Score: 0

Zachary Levi

as Bruce Banner in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +1

Evan Todd

as Thor in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +1

Anthony Ramos

as Loki in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +1

Reeve Carney

as Peter Parker in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +2

Ethan Slater

as Peter Parker in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +2

Jeremy Jordan

as Bucky Barnes in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +5

Daniel Durant

as Clint Barton in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +4

Reeve Carney

as Pre-Serum Steve Rogers in Rogers: the Musical

Score: +3